Nooooooooooooooo. Definitely not.
Played sports throughout jr high and high school and was pretty good, but never considered myself athletic. My classmates didn't either...even though by the time I graduated I had 7 athletic letters. I was known as the art and music guy since I was very good at those (and still am). Hated sports, actually, because of all the taunting and gay-bashing names.
Played intramural sports in college to be social, but was never the star. Again, never got the chance because nobody saw me that way no matter how well I did on the field.
Then I started playing flag football with the gay group out here in LA. Suddenly playing gay football made me a jock. Go figure. Now I love sports and a lot of the gay guys I work with refer to me as the "jock sports dude guy".
Funny: When I was in the closet, I hated sports and no one saw me as athletic. I came out, and suddenly sports were fun and I'm an early pic in team selections. I should have come out sooner than I did.
Happy V-day, y'all.