I'm not a New Yorker anymore, but I've eaten there a couple times. Once was for brunch which was really good. The second time for lunch and it wasn't good. Then, I had a "blind" date at dinner and it was good as well. So, for me at least, it was hit or miss, but mainly hit. Like most places in Chelsea, the wait staff can be either amazing or horrific. I always ate outside, so I can't comment on the interior at all.