Lady Gaga's Born this way vs Katy Perry's ET

  • dantheman88

    Posts: 140

    Apr 01, 2011 2:22 AM GMT
    Both videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 2:25 AM GMT
    flame war....
  • dantheman88

    Posts: 140

    Apr 01, 2011 2:53 AM GMT










  • ohioguy12

    Posts: 2024

    Apr 01, 2011 4:40 AM GMT
    I'm neither a Gaga nor Katy Perry fan, but ET sucks. Born this way isn't bad though
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 4:51 AM GMT
    ET is the better song imo, but both videos are trying WAY too hard. At least katy looks good at the end of that vid.
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 5:02 AM GMT
    Katy Perry turned into the bastard daughter of Björk and Marilyn Manson. ET wins.
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 5:08 AM GMT
    I think everyone would enjoy music a little bit more if we stopped comparing every female artist. Every time a song or music video comes out I hear "that sounds just like." I'm getting tired of it.

    That said, I really like both videos. I actually don't think they're very similar. Sci-fi elements, sure. But that's about it. Props to both women for working it out!
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 5:12 AM GMT
    Firework!
  • groundcombat

    Posts: 945

    Apr 01, 2011 5:16 AM GMT
    I don't really see them as similar either.
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 5:34 AM GMT
    CHIdude saidFirework!



    I agree however I like what Katy Perry did in ET she kept to the solid theme of aliens and each of them was more biazarre but each beautiful in a very alien manner. I like the massage that Gaga has in her song I was born the way I am take it or leave it. So I say for music video creative K. Perry for message behind a song I say Gaga.

    And their ends the thread
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 5:37 AM GMT
    E.T.

    Born this Way was a huge WTF.
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 5:40 AM GMT
    Illuminati ;)
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 6:08 AM GMT
    E.T. for sure..
    gaga's song is amazing, but the video.. its just way too much for me.
  • coastguy90814

    Posts: 661

    Apr 01, 2011 6:11 AM GMT
    radicalguy saidBoth videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?


    Like Katy Perry and E.T. but there's no comparison here ON SO MANY LEVELS.
  • dantheman88

    Posts: 140

    Apr 01, 2011 6:15 AM GMT
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy saidBoth videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?


    Like Katy Perry and E.T. but there's no comparison here ON SO MANY LEVELS.



    As an artist I truly think Katy Perry is just as talented as Lady Gaga. Watch katy perry mtv unplugged.
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 6:17 AM GMT
    I think Katy's video is more reminiscient of a mesh of Madonna's Bedtime Story and Frozen videos.
  • coastguy90814

    Posts: 661

    Apr 01, 2011 6:22 AM GMT
    radicalguy said
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy saidBoth videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?


    Like Katy Perry and E.T. but there's no comparison here ON SO MANY LEVELS.



    As an artist I truly think Katy Perry is just as talented as Lady Gaga. Watch katy perry mtv unplugged.


    No one is saying Katy is talented, I'm the first to turn her up in my car but GaGa is really on a whole different level creatively. GaGa lives and breaths music, fashion, etc; it truly is her life, not to mention she writes and produces all her music as well as has an amazing voice LIVE and is a musically trained musician. Love Katy but can't say the same about her. The clincher for me though is Gaga's fierce advocacy for Gay equal rights, she walks the talks and it's something she does to a point where is can honestly almost be a detrement to her career but she stands behind what she believes...so i have to give her the nod here.
  • dantheman88

    Posts: 140

    Apr 01, 2011 6:28 AM GMT
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy said
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy saidBoth videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?


    Like Katy Perry and E.T. but there's no comparison here ON SO MANY LEVELS.



    As an artist I truly think Katy Perry is just as talented as Lady Gaga. Watch katy perry mtv unplugged.


    No one is saying Katy is talented, I'm the first to turn her up in my car but GaGa is really on a whole different level creatively. GaGa lives and breaths music, fashion, etc; it truly is her life, not to mention she writes and produces all her music as well as has an amazing voice LIVE and is a musically trained musician. Love Katy but can't say the same about her. The clincher for me though is Gaga's fierce advocacy for Gay equal rights, she walks the talks and it's something she does to a point where is can honestly almost be a detrement to her career but she stands behind what she believes...so i have to give her the nod here.


    I do agree with on on the fact that Lady gaga is an amazing artist and advocate for gay rights, but you are underestimanting katy, she is extemely talented, music has been her life since she was a little girl, she also writes her own stuff , has composed tonsss of her work. I love how hard katy perry had to work to be where she is now..it is incredible.
  • coastguy90814

    Posts: 661

    Apr 01, 2011 6:32 AM GMT
    radicalguy said
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy said
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy saidBoth videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?


    Like Katy Perry and E.T. but there's no comparison here ON SO MANY LEVELS.



    As an artist I truly think Katy Perry is just as talented as Lady Gaga. Watch katy perry mtv unplugged.


    No one is saying Katy is talented, I'm the first to turn her up in my car but GaGa is really on a whole different level creatively. GaGa lives and breaths music, fashion, etc; it truly is her life, not to mention she writes and produces all her music as well as has an amazing voice LIVE and is a musically trained musician. Love Katy but can't say the same about her. The clincher for me though is Gaga's fierce advocacy for Gay equal rights, she walks the talks and it's something she does to a point where is can honestly almost be a detrement to her career but she stands behind what she believes...so i have to give her the nod here.


    I do agree with on on the fact that Lady gaga is an amazing artist and advocate for gay rights, but you are underestimanting katy, she is extemely talented, music has been her life since she was a little girl, she also writes her own stuff , has composed tonsss of her work. I love how hard katy perry had to work to be where she is now..it is incredible.


    Yup I hear you bro, like Katy a lot, really do, she is very talented but I still have to give GaGa the edge here, especially when it comes to performing live. I thought it was pretty cool though seeing Katy perform Born This Way acoustic.
  • Posted by a hidden member.
    Log in to view his profile

    Apr 01, 2011 6:41 AM GMT
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy said
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy said
    coastguy90814 said
    radicalguy saidBoth videos are a bit similar.Which one do you think is the best? and why?


    Like Katy Perry and E.T. but there's no comparison here ON SO MANY LEVELS.



    As an artist I truly think Katy Perry is just as talented as Lady Gaga. Watch katy perry mtv unplugged.


    No one is saying Katy is talented, I'm the first to turn her up in my car but GaGa is really on a whole different level creatively. GaGa lives and breaths music, fashion, etc; it truly is her life, not to mention she writes and produces all her music as well as has an amazing voice LIVE and is a musically trained musician. Love Katy but can't say the same about her. The clincher for me though is Gaga's fierce advocacy for Gay equal rights, she walks the talks and it's something she does to a point where is can honestly almost be a detrement to her career but she stands behind what she believes...so i have to give her the nod here.


    I do agree with on on the fact that Lady gaga is an amazing artist and advocate for gay rights, but you are underestimanting katy, she is extemely talented, music has been her life since she was a little girl, she also writes her own stuff , has composed tonsss of her work. I love how hard katy perry had to work to be where she is now..it is incredible.


    Yup I hear you bro, like Katy a lot, really do, she is very talented but I still have to give GaGa the edge here, especially when it comes to performing live. I thought it was pretty cool though seeing Katy perform Born This Way acoustic.


    Just one thing about the Lady GaGa comment on Gay rights...she supports the LGBTQ community so much not only cuz she's a gay icon, but also cuz she is a member of the LGBTQ community.