Nissan Altima Coupe
Hyundai Genesis Coupe
or do I just suck it up and buy a Prius, given gas prices...
Of your choices I would think about the Subaru or the Hyundai. The Subaru is about to be updated to the new Impreza within the year I believe (I could be wrong, in that case someone please inform me). The updated Hyundai looks really nice and is a decent car!
The Altima looks like a watered down G37, good car but rather bland. A manual V6 version could be fun though! I almost bought a RX-8 a few years ago, nice car, drove great, awesome manual, however I hesitated due to the maintanance upkeep and it burns a lot of oil! They have stopped production as well of the RX-8.
Please don't buy a Prius...if you enjoy driving cars, the Prius isn't a car guys kind of car. No offense to anyone. Good luck!