AMoonHawk saidHe does have that mistaken gay look because he is always smiling like he knows something you don't. Most straight guys purposely have that permanent scowl on their face ( I won't go into why here). His facial expression is also the look of those that believed they are saved. Contented. Some gay men (not lesbians -- they have a scowl too) have that same facial expression, that's how you can clock them sometimes and why people mistake Tim's look for a gay look. He is pretty though!
Gay or straight... if you hang around females mostly growing up and during puberty, you're going to naturally have feminine tendencies unless you make an effort to be masc. Anytime a straight guy is feminine, he is assumed to be in the closet until proven straight (which is never). Girls tend to smile with their teeth clenched and their eyes squinted. Guys tend to smile with their mouths open.
He may indeed be gay. If so, I empathize with him because we know how hard it is to be raised in an extremely religious family knowing we might be rejected. As an athlete, it's gotta be even worse. Given all the posts about how cruel and judgemental gays are to each other, I hope he stays in the closet until he's comfortable. IF he's gay that is.