FORUMS > Spirituality Forum Rules

Balancing Christianity and Homosexuality

  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 2:44 AM GMT
    No One is Perfect, Gay or Not, we are sinful and will always be. Even if we are saved or born again..we still will sin.

    Even if you think being gay is wrong, you still would have sin if you are straight, and all sins are equal if you go by the bible you are applying your reasoning too.
  • imperator Posts: 625
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 3:00 AM GMT
    big_nick_86 saidHey guys,
    I am a young gay Christian male. I believe homosexuality is a sin just like any other sin such as murdering or gossiping. I hate it that I am gay however I have had homosexual relationships I have come out to my friends but am considering just suppressing my homosexual side and just maybe being single for the rest of my life I don't really know. Whenever I am in a homosexual relationship and it gets serious or goes for a relatively long time period I start feeling even more guilty and am forced to break up with him. I am really lost don't know what to do or feel. I can't abandon my faith. Thoughts? Experiences? Anybody willing to talk about this? I can skype or message or whatever.
    Many thanks,
    L



    If you feel like your religion and your sexual orientation can't be reconciled, I'd suggest dispensing with your religion. You were born with your orientation, you were taught your religion. One is natural, one is conditioning. Re-condition yourself. Learn a new religion-- one that doesn't feed you made up nonsense that conflicts with your good, wholesome human birthright-- or just cast it aside altogether.

    We are not wicked beings born tainted and in need of some outside intervention to 'redeem us.' We start out good, like babies, and are taught all of our 'vices'-- selfishness and delusion and confusion-- and told that they're our nature so we'll turn to power-hungry 'holy' men to cleanse and forgive us. It's a sham, and you can do better.
  • meninlove Posts: 27379
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 4:13 AM GMT
    JamieJfromtheA saidNo One is Perfect, Gay or Not, we are sinful and will always be. Even if we are saved or born again..we still will sin.

    Even if you think being gay is wrong, you still would have sin if you are straight, and all sins are equal if you go by the bible you are applying your reasoning too.


    Hmmm....I feel that if we focus and obsess on sin in ourselves and others there is no room for the joys of the existence given to us and the joy in the existence of others.

    If all sins are equal, wouldn't that mean the sin of not honouring the father that beat and raped you (which happens to some people, just read the news) is the same as the sin of murder?

    Commandment 5

    intrigued,

    -Doug



  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 4:16 AM GMT
    meninlove said
    JamieJfromtheA saidNo One is Perfect, Gay or Not, we are sinful and will always be. Even if we are saved or born again..we still will sin.

    Even if you think being gay is wrong, you still would have sin if you are straight, and all sins are equal if you go by the bible you are applying your reasoning too.


    Hmmm....I feel that if we focus and obsess on sin in ourselves and others there is no room for the joys of the existence given to us and the joy in the existence of others.

    If all sins are equal, wouldn't that mean the sin of not honouring the father that beat and raped you (which happens to some people, just read the news) is the same as the sin of murder?

    Commandment 5

    intrigued,

    -Doug





    But not all sin is equal; this is the teaching.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 4:57 AM GMT
    So much jargon gets thrown about with this type of discussion. Often our own cultural understanding of teaching that was recorded thousands of years ago in multiple other languages (Hebrew, Aramaic and other tongues), gets quoted in the tiniest of phrases, and is somehow used to prove or disprove what is right and what is wrong.

    As the child of an ordained minister and growing up in a Pentecostal church for my entire childhood, I learned a lot of things about life. For one, that nothing is black and white, that EVERYONE and I mean EVERYONE has done things that are considered pretty big sins according to the teachings of the modern day churches.

    There were forced weddings after girls get pregnant, date rape, stealing, coercion, abuse, people pushed into taking anti-psychotic medications, and most of these things were enabled by people who all thought they were doing it in the name of what is good and right, some who were naive and more often than not those higher up who were trying to cover up these shameful acts to the detriment of others.

    The truth is all of these things happen regardless of whether you grow up in a church or not, it's just that 'religion' tells us to pretend like it doesn't. That somehow by believing in God we suddenly become better than the rest of our fellow humans on the planet. "Religion" is really our enemy here, not belief. It's the big systems of religion that teach people to throw aside commandments like:

    1 Corinthians 13:13 "And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love."


    and put more emphasis on verses like this:

    1 Leviticus 18:22 "Do not have sexual relations with a man as one does with a woman; that is detestable. "


    One pastor really woke me up one day when I heard the way he spoke about the bible. What is rarely taught, and often de-emphasised is that the bible is collection of writings from the spiritual people of that day. The old testament is primarily written to the Jewish people, because Christianity came out of the Jewish faith.

    Most Christians seem to loathe this fact, and pretty much ignore our Jewish brethren, even though most of the bible is entirely written from their perspective. This fact however brings to light new understanding. For instance, Leviticus is part of the old testament and was written to the Jewish people.

    When you think about it, having a rule against homosexuality sort of makes sense in these conditions. When you have a small group of surviving Jewish people who escaped from Egypt after being enslaved for hundreds of years, it's more important for people to pro-create to prolong the race then it is for you to have your own person happiness. Guys like us would have families so that our children could grow up and become strong and protect us as we got older. If everyone did as they wished, the Jewish people may not have survived.

    However there is a lot of speculation if this rule was even interpreted from the ancient languages correctly or if it was really speaking against male prostitution as it was highly popular in other cultures of that day. Then we also have to ask ourselves, which person of that day decreed these laws? Where did they come from. Ultimately, who is saying this, and who are they talking to?

    Here's a great quote on the whole "Gays are an abomination" topic that comes up so often by the crazy hate-filled right wingers:

    "Lev 20:13 is giving the penalties for the Lev 18:22 "abomination" or in the Hebrew "toevah" Unlike what the English translation implies, toevah did not usually signify something intrinsically evil, but something ritually unclean for Jews. Eating pork, shellfish, lobster, eating meat 3 days old, trimming beards, etc is just as much an "abomination". It is used throughout the [Old Testament] to designate those Jewish sins which involve ethnic contamination or idolatry. In many other [Old Testament] verses it simply means idolatry. Lev 18 is specifically designed to distinguish the Jews from the pagans among whom they had been living. The prohibition of supposedly homosexual acts follows after the prohibition of idolatrous sexuality of worshipping Molech, whose cult included male cult prostitutes and bestiality. "
    (You can read more here: http://www.lionking.org/~kovu/bible/section05.html)

    I think what bothers the fundamental Christians so much about gay people is that we show that the world is nuanced. We challenge their faith. Us existing and genuinely searching for happiness, and finding strength within ourselves to be who we truly are means that for once they have to face their own selves. To realize that their cobbled together, culturally-biased and misinformed interpretation of the bible that has proliferated through our society for the past 200 hundred years is flawed, and that it's time that they wake up to the world for what is really is, and not what they wished it was.

    It's a generation of people who want to live in a Leave It To Beaver, black and white world, when really it's all just a lot of shades of grey. I pray for a day when people can find the peace with all the shades and tones in the world around them and within themselves, while still striving to the be the best people they can be.

    A long spiel I know, but it's a complex subject. Just my take on the whole thing.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 1:50 PM GMT
    To Meninlove,

    Having checked the article, yes I did say "gay lifestyle." But I had never thought that you or any other reader would find the expression offensive. In honestly, the whole article was in defense for LGBT, and against churches or religious leaders passing judgement. I did not like what these groups were up to, therefore when London mayor Boris Johnson decided to make a stand, it was worth writing about.

    I have checked the meaning of the word "lifestyle" in the dictionary. It simply means "The way in which the person lives".
    Does this indicate the choices a person makes? Don't we all make choices? The very fact that I typed in the word and then need to be reminded that it was there, and even asked where it was, indicated that there was no malicious intent in word choosing when I composed the article.

    You made several points about Paul's first letter to the church in Corinth. All he was saying that it would be good if Christians remained single, as this would open up full devotion to the Lord. But he was also aware that not every Christian had that kind of ability to remain celibate. Therefore he would be better off to marry than to burn with passion.

    And here is where I differ from the Roman Catholic Church on this issue. The Catechism should never have imposed the clergy to remain celibate! It was wholly against human nature and as it stands, a grave sin against God.

    As for gay relationships, when I was young (and far better looking than at present) - I too could have chosen to live with a male partner. I had not a few offers. But for personal reasons, I chose not to. I could put this down to religious conviction. Yes, there is some truth in this. But that wasn't all. Rather, the thought of having sex with another male did not appeal to me in the natural sense. It was very much as not liking garlic on my dinner plate.

    There is no doubt that you and Bill have a very healthy relationship. You each chose each other to be together. I am very aware that many churches would pass judgement on your relationship. Little wonder that the vast majority of homosexuals despise organised Christianity, particularly of the Fred Phelps type. It is those kind of people I disagree with, and said so in my blog.

    But for me, I would in no way pass judgement. Or not even my opinion. The matter is strictly between Bill, yourself and God.

    Personally, I wish that I can believe freely that God has blessed your marriage. Nothing is more endearing than seeing two people in a loving relationship. And the Bible does say that when men get on so well, its like the oil which ran down the cheek of Aaron, a very pleasant, sweet odour to the Lord.

    But any doubts that I have stem more from confusion and uncertainty, and definitely NOT in any way judgement, censorship or even an opinion.

    I hope both of you enjoy a very good relationship.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 2:10 PM GMT
    if other people can reconcile eating shellfish, wearing poly-cotton blends, lying, and fornicating before entering heaven....then surely the OP can reconcile having gay sex. i never understood what the big deal was.

    people let the extremists of the Christian religion speak too loudly on this one issue.
  • meninlove Posts: 27379
    QUOTE Jul 15, 2012 2:21 PM GMT

    Thanks NotThatOld.
    I think you've misconstrued my post as a criticism of you personally, which it is not.

    Consider this without prejudice; you're not gay, but Bi. This is just fine.
    You had a choice in the matter, we do not.

    There lies the difference in gay being a lifestyle or not.

    As for Paul, he was as imperfect as anyone else, and it shows in his much- edited and manipulated-by-others writing, as does the rest of the bible.

    The article is sweetly worded through much of it, but in the end the teeth in the leg-hold trap are exposed.



  • bri_66 Posts: 592
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 1:53 PM GMT
    cvilleguy saidI believe in the tenet that we ALL have sinned, but that if we believe that God sent Jesus to die for our sins and redeem us, and we have faith...we will go to Heaven. Obviously this means that EVERY Christian should try to live a life that follows Biblical-New Testament principles. That means that if we become Christians and still do the same sinful things we did before we became zchristians, then it should give you pause in realizing what you need to do differently. There's a reason why you feel guilt for what you do that is not right. You could be straight, gay, whatever...it doesn't matter. If you act immorally, you won't feel good about it. You can be gay and have a Christian life if you have faith, repent if you do sin, and do your best not to do thm again. God doesn't expect us to be perfect. Jesus took that upon himself. But we do have to accept God and Jesus in our hearts.


    Agreed
  • bri_66 Posts: 592
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 2:09 PM GMT
    I also believe that those in the Old Testament were under the Old Law.
    After Jesus was born, died and resurrected, we were born into the new Kingdom of Forgiveness, Love, Grace and Mercy. The Old Laws were were born by Christ and a New Covenant was created.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 2:22 PM GMT
    Your spiritual relationship is between you and your God. Your congregation/community is secondary.

    If your current community does not support your spiritual quest then for God's sake find a more enlightened group!




  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 2:29 PM GMT
    Watch "For the Bible Tells Me So." It's on Netflix streaming as well.

  • dancedancekj Posts: 1761
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 2:54 PM GMT
    Matt_TO saidSo much jargon gets thrown about with this type of discussion. Often our own cultural understanding of teaching that was recorded thousands of years ago in multiple other languages (Hebrew, Aramaic and other tongues), gets quoted in the tiniest of phrases, and is somehow used to prove or disprove what is right and what is wrong.

    As the child of an ordained minister and growing up in a Pentecostal church for my entire childhood, I learned a lot of things about life. For one, that nothing is black and white, that EVERYONE and I mean EVERYONE has done things that are considered pretty big sins according to the teachings of the modern day churches.

    There were forced weddings after girls get pregnant, date rape, stealing, coercion, abuse, people pushed into taking anti-psychotic medications, and most of these things were enabled by people who all thought they were doing it in the name of what is good and right, some who were naive and more often than not those higher up who were trying to cover up these shameful acts to the detriment of others.

    The truth is all of these things happen regardless of whether you grow up in a church or not, it's just that 'religion' tells us to pretend like it doesn't. That somehow by believing in God we suddenly become better than the rest of our fellow humans on the planet. "Religion" is really our enemy here, not belief. It's the big systems of religion that teach people to throw aside commandments like:

    1 Corinthians 13:13 "And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love."


    and put more emphasis on verses like this:

    1 Leviticus 18:22 "Do not have sexual relations with a man as one does with a woman; that is detestable. "


    One pastor really woke me up one day when I heard the way he spoke about the bible. What is rarely taught, and often de-emphasised is that the bible is collection of writings from the spiritual people of that day. The old testament is primarily written to the Jewish people, because Christianity came out of the Jewish faith.

    Most Christians seem to loathe this fact, and pretty much ignore our Jewish brethren, even though most of the bible is entirely written from their perspective. This fact however brings to light new understanding. For instance, Leviticus is part of the old testament and was written to the Jewish people.

    When you think about it, having a rule against homosexuality sort of makes sense in these conditions. When you have a small group of surviving Jewish people who escaped from Egypt after being enslaved for hundreds of years, it's more important for people to pro-create to prolong the race then it is for you to have your own person happiness. Guys like us would have families so that our children could grow up and become strong and protect us as we got older. If everyone did as they wished, the Jewish people may not have survived.

    However there is a lot of speculation if this rule was even interpreted from the ancient languages correctly or if it was really speaking against male prostitution as it was highly popular in other cultures of that day. Then we also have to ask ourselves, which person of that day decreed these laws? Where did they come from. Ultimately, who is saying this, and who are they talking to?

    Here's a great quote on the whole "Gays are an abomination" topic that comes up so often by the crazy hate-filled right wingers:

    "Lev 20:13 is giving the penalties for the Lev 18:22 "abomination" or in the Hebrew "toevah" Unlike what the English translation implies, toevah did not usually signify something intrinsically evil, but something ritually unclean for Jews. Eating pork, shellfish, lobster, eating meat 3 days old, trimming beards, etc is just as much an "abomination". It is used throughout the [Old Testament] to designate those Jewish sins which involve ethnic contamination or idolatry. In many other [Old Testament] verses it simply means idolatry. Lev 18 is specifically designed to distinguish the Jews from the pagans among whom they had been living. The prohibition of supposedly homosexual acts follows after the prohibition of idolatrous sexuality of worshipping Molech, whose cult included male cult prostitutes and bestiality. "
    (You can read more here: http://www.lionking.org/~kovu/bible/section05.html)

    I think what bothers the fundamental Christians so much about gay people is that we show that the world is nuanced. We challenge their faith. Us existing and genuinely searching for happiness, and finding strength within ourselves to be who we truly are means that for once they have to face their own selves. To realize that their cobbled together, culturally-biased and misinformed interpretation of the bible that has proliferated through our society for the past 200 hundred years is flawed, and that it's time that they wake up to the world for what is really is, and not what they wished it was.

    It's a generation of people who want to live in a Leave It To Beaver, black and white world, when really it's all just a lot of shades of grey. I pray for a day when people can find the peace with all the shades and tones in the world around them and within themselves, while still striving to the be the best people they can be.

    A long spiel I know, but it's a complex subject. Just my take on the whole thing.


    QFT
  • redsoxfan791 Posts: 1607
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 3:25 PM GMT
    Outlands saidDude, you had better realize who and what you are and get over it. Sounds tough, but if your faith doesn't allow you to be yourself, how can you believe in something that doesn't believe in you?


    I'm not religious at all, but its possible to be a non-denominational Christian who understands the true message of Christianity without the judgment humans add to the equation.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Aug 23, 2012 3:43 PM GMT
    I don't have time to read every comment on this topic but just know that I share in your struggle. I'm a Christian. I am tormented daily by the thoughts of ''you're going to hell.'' We have to rely on GRACE.

    2 Corinthians 12:7 reads:

    This is the Apostle Paul speaking: "To keep me from becoming conceited because of these surpassingly great revelations, there was given me a thorn in my flesh (Bible doesn't specify what that thorn was), a messenger of Satan, to torment me. Three times I pleaded with the Lord to take it away from me. But he said to me, "MY GRACE IS SUFFICIENT FOR YOU, for my power is made perfect in weakness.''
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 5:19 AM GMT
    The Bible doesn't say homosexuality is a sin. It refers to sexual acts other than intercourse as a sin. People fail to take into account that the overpopulation was hardly an issue back then.
  • jurog5 Posts: 137
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 5:22 AM GMT
    Why would you believe in something that is destroying you? Doesn't make sense to me.

    Why don't you forget about god, heaven.. hell or whatever.. and try to live a happy life?
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 5:37 AM GMT
    Do you think you will go through life without sinning.Believing that all sins have the same gravity is nonsense.Dont crucify yourself.I am a believing Catholic..every person has faults.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 5:45 AM GMT
    You can't give up something you believe your whole life (Religion) because of bias reasons (being a homosexual). I say if you believe in God, you can conquer anything. Have a good emotional support, but don't do homosexual activities. Being gay is not a sin, homosexual activities is (according to most religion). I know you are going via rough patch but remember this world is temporary and we are all tested with difficulties.
  • He_Man Posts: 904
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 6:31 AM GMT

    Here's an interesting view of religions and religious people by Dr. Robert Sapolsky from Standford University. He argues that religious founders, along with most highly religious people, suffer from some form of schiztotypal disorder and that ritualistic habits are a form of OCD. This video is the first part of six videos on Youtube, which I recommend you to watch. I suggest looking into it for a starter.

  • Hard_gainer Posts: 64
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 7:02 AM GMT
    This is nothing but an opinion
    None of us choose to be gay and if we had a choice none of us would choose to be. You chose religion, to devote your life to your god and have faith in him. I just do not understand nor ever will, the hatred Christianity has towards homosexuality. If you chose to be a devout Christian you can then choose not to be one surely?
    Put some faith in yourself, your humanity, instead of Christianity. Your friends are all sinners anyway undoubtedly so what difference does it make. You have the right to be happy and lead a life free from restraint and guilt and its clear your religion won't allow you to have that freedom ever so that is your choice really and whatever you choose will decide whether you'll lead a life as a lie untruthfully or quit your faith and realise your dreams. its only you that has the power to break the wall down
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 7:17 AM GMT
    Thou Shalt not lie you are homo, you are homo embrace who you are and enjoy you where not born to suffer or feel inferior .

    the only reason it was sin for man to lay next to man what the Jews needed to have sex and populate ,Jesus never said anything against homos and the church and scripture are open to interpretation and manipulation .
  • Arcturian Posts: 204
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 7:39 AM GMT
    Many people have in themselves more guilt from Jesus´s death than gratefullness for his deeds...his message was love, not fear...

    Don´t forget, that by the Bible cheaters shall be stoned, girl having sex before marriage shall be killed...is it in Bible? Yes. Talks church about it? No. Why. If they respect these guidelines, they have to kill big part of population. So, those ,,sins" became tolerated. Homosexuality, not just sex, but much more love to same sex, is punished only becase it´s visible. It´s not hidden like cheating. And if You have just sex with other man - it worked for centuries - it was ok. Go out and live with other man and the hell´s flames are the only You can expect....if You accept it, btw.

    The only message from God are those 10 sentencies. Rest of the Bible is writen by humans....same as lady magazines. Imagine the prayer to Holy lipstick in 2000 years just because this magazine will be found 2000 yrs later.

    If this doesn´t help, watch gay muslims. They´re fucked much more...
  • mgmt88 Posts: 56
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 11:11 PM GMT
    homosexuality and religion doesn't work together.
  • Posted by a hidden member.Log in to view his profile
    QUOTE Jan 17, 2013 11:13 PM GMT
    Run, don't walk, to an LGBT friendly church such as the Unitarian Universalists, Episcopalians, Quakers [even some Lutherans].

    Even though I'm an atheist, I know many gay people who manage to be part of religions that actively love them.

    Don't waste your time on the intolerant, hateful scum.