MileHighYo saidYes I would, and I have. I went against one of these at some point last summer. Never mess with someone that has a hammer. Needless to say, the Magic 8 ball did not survive.
You know, of course, that there is a secret cursed demon locked inside each Magic 8 Ball. To bust one open is to free the demon(which immediately attaches and dwells within the closest toilet. You will know if your toilet is demon-possessed by any rank or putrid "poopie" odors.