Hmm, I remember seeing a guy who said he loved being emo, but his pictures made him look like a jock. Some guy commented that he should jump ship off the emo look and go with the jock look all together, but He quickly retaliated on the idea of letting go of his emo look. I gave him mad props for sticking with what he likes, instead of following what other jocks said about him.
I consider myself an artistic dancer, and I've gotten mixed messages with guys on how they feel about that. Some think it's like the most weirdest thing, and tarnishes the masculine look, and can't really compute on how they feel about it. Then there are some guys who think it's hot. So, I dunno if calling someone a geek or alt/punk abnormal. But I do feel like being "non-jock" especially on this site, you are categorized differently, (at least for me, on how I feel) for better or worse it's different from person to person.