AyaTrollah pouncer saidnot only is there no French or Polish "ethnicity"
In order to deny Jews their ethnicity without appearing to be an Anti-Semite, AyaTrollah pouncer now seeks to deny any and all ethnicities in the modern world?http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poles
A> his own source:
|| a nation of predominantly West Slavic ethnic origin
Nation as used here is not synonymous with State, which is why rather than quote from the article, we get the usual idiotic twisting:
A> That is, the opposite of an "ethnicity" - a nation with a majority (Slavic) and minority (German, Gypsy...) ethnic origins - both irrelevant to the status of who is Polish in 2015.
So while there is no Polish ethnicity, there are Slavic, German and "Gypsy" ethnicities?
Yet Germans make up 0.2% of Polish citizens, "Gypsies" even less.
This makes Pole as an ethnicity disappear?
But wait, when we look at Germany... we see that it has a minority of ethnic Poles listed, just as there are ethnic Germans in Poland.
|| Chicago, in the United States, had the world's largest urban Polish population after Warsaw.How many Poles living in Chicago do you suppose are citizens of the Polish state? Lacking Polish citizenship, what makes the 90+% of them ethnic Poles?
A> If someone or their family has origins in Poland, they are Polish. If someone immigrates to Poland from Somalia and takes out Polish citizenship, they are Polish.
Yes, but these are two different types of "Polish".
The former is a non-Citizen who is ETHNICALLY Polish.
The latter is a Citizen who is of Somali ethnicity (you yourself argued that someone born a Somali can't "convert" to be Polish.)What if a Polish woman (who according to the AyaTrollah has no ethnicity) marries a Hungarian and adopts Magyar ethnicity. Has she "converted"? What about their children? Are they ethnic Magyars or in AyaTrollah pouncer's racist eyes worthless half-breeds?
A> A Brazilian who marries a "Magyar" no more becomes a "Magyar" than one who marries a Kurd becomes a Kurd. They may become a "Magyar" (read Hungarian) citizen, or a Kurdish citizen were Kurdistan a state, but a person does not add or subtract "ethnicities".
There is no Kurdish state, no Kurdistan. So how can someone be "Kurdish"?
So is there or isn't there Polish ethnicity?
A> There is no Polish "ethnicity" in 2015
. Polish communities in Germany or America are communities of Polish origin, no one cares what their "ethnicity" is
You contradict yourself. First asserting they aren't of Polish ethnicity, then claiming it's irrelevant if they are.
They care. They belong to fraternal groups and have museums and parades, etc.
But do provide us with a few more laughs: what year did Polish ethnicity end?
A> Children, that is descendents, are different, as they can be Hungarian or Kurdish by origin (jus sanguinis - which as explained has nothing to do with "blood" but parentage).
What? You "explained" it "has nothing to do with 'blood'" when you've devoted so much time to arguments of racial purity?!
A> one is either a Jew (ie. of Jewish religion or parentage)
Where "parentage" is ethnicity, so there is Jewish ethnicity.
A> ?Amongst Iran's Jews 2500 years ago, which he identified as an ethnic group, "conversion" to that ethnic group WAS possible.