Binghamton is an old, declining industrial city in New York's southern tier region that used to be well known for being very intolerant and mostly white bread. But that was back then this is now. Like every place in America and the rest of the world, Binghamton is changing demographically. It still does not change the fact that this was a horrible, inexcusable act of violence against innocent immigrants who wanted to become part of America and seek a better, more prosperous life. This is just horrible.