Both of them are so International Male circa 1998!
Something a little short and form fitting, like a biker jacket (no, not the Michael Jackson multizippered crap!) or a bomber jacket in black leather.
If you can find a two or one button tailored cut leather blazer, that would be better.
All of these jackets can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. And check out thrift stores; you'd be pleasantly surprised at what you'd find there.
If you'd like to go designer, Gucci, Dolce & Gabbana and Hugo Boss makes these kinds of jackets i've suggested.
Have fun shopping!